A few years ago a mentor suggested the title to this blog as marketing message. While we’ve never had the guts to put it out there, it contains an inescapable logic that we believe all business owners should embrace. We explain why.
Let’s say your Profit and Loss last year looked like this:
Revenue £250,000
Cost of Sales £130,000
Gross Profit £120,000
Overheads £70,000
Profit before Tax £50,000
Tax @ 20% £10,000
Profit after Tax £40,000
Let’s also say you have £200 to spend on accounting services. At Co- that would equate to a few hours work.
One thing I could do would be to look for tax savings. If I am lucky you are new to us and your previous accountant has not done a great job on advising here. If I am doing well I might find another £5k of tax deductible expenditure you have already been spending that can go through the business as a tax deduction. This would save you £1k in tax.
Much more likely is that everything that can be done has been done. Certainly if we have done our job in year 1 we are unlikely to find much if anything thereafter. At the scale of small business, the scope for a bright idea in tax is vanishingly small because everything has been tried before and either closed off by HMRC or made legitimate.
Alternatively we could work with you on some development plans. Maybe we can work through some investment numbers that allow you to increase your prices or get more business.
If our work results in a 5% increase in the price you charge, you have put £10k in your pocket after tax. If our work results in a 5% increase in volume of business, I have put £5k in your pocket after tax.
My chances of spotting something that will make a 5% difference like that are immeasurably larger than finding a new tax break. If we compound the gain over 5 years the difference in value provided between work that helps increase your price and work that finds a £1k tax saving is now £45k. For the helping increase volume we have a £20k difference.
Now here is the rub, if we help you increase your price, you will be paying more tax. In the scenario we work on price it will be £2.5k more each year. In the scenario we work on volume it will be £1k more each year.
Many many business owners are continually asking their accountant to find a way to pay less tax, very few are asking them for ideas to make more profit. Equally most accountants go to market on proposition they will save their clients tax.
It’s important to say at this point that we are in favour of both activities. In fact we are proud of our tax service which consists of:
Review of Tax at engagement
Annual Business Tax Planning Review: VAT; Tax deductible expenditure; Capital Allowances; Tax Credits; Employers NI
Annual Personal Tax Planning Review: Mix of Income Streams (salary, dividend, trading, rent etc); Tax Reliefs (pension, charitable giving); timing of dividend
But we are also mindful that we should never lose sight of which activity will support our clients more.